When “Success” Is Not an Outcome: Ninety-Day Ascertainment and Continuity of Care in Islamabad Residential Drug Rehabilitation

Authors

  • Fida Muhammad Khan Assistant Professor at PIDE School of Policy,, Development and Governance , at the Pakistan Institute of development economics, Islamabad.
  • Musharaf Abbas Teaching Assistant and Research scholar PIDE School of Policy,, Development and Governance , at the Pakistan Institute of development economics, Islamabad.

Keywords:

substance use disorders; residential rehabilitation; continuity of care; outcome ascertainment; missing data; Pakistan

Abstract

Introduction: Residential rehabilitation reports can conflate programme completion, contact after discharge and sustained recovery. This paper examines ninety-day outcome ascertainment and continuity of care using institutional data from fifteen residential drug rehabilitation centres in Islamabad, Pakistan. Methods: We analysed aggregated centre-level questionnaire data and interpretive interview material from rehabilitation professionals. Denominators across the post-discharge pathway were reconstructed to distinguish discharge, follow-up contact and completed outcome assessment. Because the available evidence was aggregate and centre-reported, the analysis evaluates outcome ascertainment and reporting practices rather than treatment efficacy. Results: The study dataset included 870 discharges eligible for follow-up, 400 contacted (46.0%), and 360 with an assessed substance-use status (41.4%). Among the assessed group, 200 had a recorded return to use and 160 did not. Outcomes remained unascertained for 510 eligible discharges (58.6%). The 55.6% return-to-use proportion among assessed cases cannot represent all eligible discharges. Management-reported success claims were not based on comparable documented outcome definitions. Conclusions: The available evidence supports a finding of incomplete outcome ascertainment, not a credible cohort-wide relapse rate or estimate of treatment efficacy. A transparent monitoring system should distinguish eligibility, contact, assessment, return to use, and continuing service engagement.

Published

2026-11-10

How to Cite

Fida Muhammad Khan, & Musharaf Abbas. (2026). When “Success” Is Not an Outcome: Ninety-Day Ascertainment and Continuity of Care in Islamabad Residential Drug Rehabilitation . Review of Crime, Peace and Society, 3(9), 97–110. Retrieved from https://reviewcps.com/index.php/rcps/article/view/336

Similar Articles

<< < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.