Special Economic Zones in Pakistan: Why Are They Underperforming?

Authors

  • Dr. Musarat Amin Associate Professor, Jinnah School of Public Policy (JSPPL), Head of the Centre for Interdisciplinary Social Sciences.NUST
  • Gen.(Retd).Dr. Muhammad Samrez Salik Professor of Practice at National University of Sciences and Technology (NUST) Islamabad.

Keywords:

special economic zones, Pakistan, CPEC, industrial policy, governance, foreign direct investment, local communities, security

Abstract

Special Economic Zones (SEZs) are intended to revitalize and transform Pakistan’s industries. SEZs created under CPEC have prioritized 9 zones. Pakistan passed the Special Economic Zones Act in 2012 and, with it, aimed to realize over US$8 billion Foreign Direct Investment and 500,000 jobs in 6 years. The targets were not met. Only 4 of the 9 CPEC zones progressed from the planning to the implementation stage. It is estimated Pakistan’s SEZs contribute 0.5% to the country’s GDP. This study explores the reasons for underperformance. It employs a multi-disciplinary approach to analyze available literature and policy frameworks. The approaches, spanning security to governance to local populations, are pillars of a comprehensive strategy to appraise the status and prospects of SEZs in Pakistan.

The paper highlights that underperformance is systematic, not incidental. From a strategic viewpoint, the location of the zones was the result of negotiations. Demand analyses were generally not conducted. Furthermore, the zones relied on tax holidays to gain competitive edge. Regarding the operation of the zones, the availability and cost of utilities was a major constraint. Security concerns concerning Chinese nationals resulted in cost increases. fragments of the state (e.g. Police) are duplicated at the provincial level. Hence, in practice, the “one window” operation is largely non-existent. Displacement and insufficient and slow compensation have resulted in popular hostility towards the zones.

The paper identifies practices in China, Bangladesh and Vietnam, and suggests prioritizing and advancing reforms in the following order: abandonment and/or removal of stalled zones; transition from taxes to fees and subsidies; assurance of utilities; improvement in the professionalism of zone administration; and incorporation of the legislative and policy frameworks for inter-state (federal and provincial) collaboration as well as benefit-sharing at the local level. The resourcefulness of the states is constrained by the lack of legitimate institutions, and in some cases, constructively engaged the state.

Published

2026-06-30

How to Cite

Dr. Musarat Amin, & Gen.(Retd).Dr. Muhammad Samrez Salik. (2026). Special Economic Zones in Pakistan: Why Are They Underperforming?. Review of Crime, Peace and Society, 3(3), 513–527. Retrieved from https://reviewcps.com/index.php/rcps/article/view/332

Similar Articles

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.